diff --git a/script.js b/script.js
index 6b5ea22..56e316c 100644
--- a/script.js
+++ b/script.js
@@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ let commonPhrases = [
     {phrase: 'Nativity with no Baby Jesus', multiple: true, list: 'common'},
 
     //creepy
-    {phrase: 'Creepy Nativity', multiple: true, list: 'common'},
+    {phrase: 'Creepy Nativity', multiple: false, list: 'common'},
     {phrase: 'Creepy Santa', multiple: true, list: 'common'},
     {phrase: 'Creepy Snowman', multiple: true, list: 'common'},